New measurements of the WASP-47 System Point to a Puzzling Formation History

A team led by iREx researcher Lauren Weiss combined measurements from the W. M. Keck Observatory in Hawaii and the Kepler Space Telescope to study the four known planets around WASP-47, a solar-like star located 650 light-years away. The results suggest its intriguing planetary system might have formed in two distinct stages.

Most known hot Jupiters – giant planets really close to their stars – are solitary planets. Astronomers believe that the formation of these giant planets prevents the formation of other. WASP-47 is an exception. It hosts a hot Jupiter, two smaller planets orbiting closer and farther to the star than the hot Jupiter, and a much more distant giant planet. The four planets were previously detected with ground-based instruments and the Kepler Space Telescope.

WASP-47 is a rare case of a star that hosts both a hot Jupiter and other planets. This doodle by Dr Weiss shows the hot Jupiter WASP-47 b and immediate neighbors WASP-47 e, a planet 1.7 times the size of the Earth orbiting closer to the star in just 0.8 days, and WASP-47 d, a planet 3.6 times the size of the Earth orbiting farther from the star, in a 9 day orbit. A more distant giant planet, WASP-47 c, orbits the star in 600 days. By Lauren Weiss

The new study determines the masses, densities, compositions, and orbits of the planets to high precision using both radial velocity (RV) measurements from the Keck HIRES instrument and transit timing variation (TTV) measurements from Kepler. Only a few planetary systems can be studied with the two methods. The RV method, which measures the wobble of the star from the gravitational pull of all its planets, requires a bright star, while the TTV method, which measures the gravitational pull the planets exert on each other, slightly speeding up or slowing down their orbits every time the planets pass each other, requires closely packed planets. WASP-47 has both.

The very good precision results obtained by Weiss and her team show that the two giant planets WASP-47 b and WASP-47 c are each at least the mass of Jupiter, whereas the small planets WASP-47 e and d are 9 and 14 times the mass of Earth, respectively. The two Jupiter-mass planets have most of their mass in gas, but the two small planets have most of their mass in rock. WASP-47 e has a density consistent with a rocky surface composition like Earth, while WASP-47 d has a much smaller density, suggesting about 1% of its mass is in a thick gaseous envelope.

How did WASP-47 b become 40 times more massive than its immediate neighbors?  The team proposes a new model of planet formation, called the two-stages planet formation. In this hypothesis, the giant planets form first in the gas disk, when more gas is available. Later, when most of the gas has been blown away, the smaller planets can form in a gas-poor environment.

Another interesting aspect of the system, confirmed by the study, is that the three innermost planets have nearly circular orbits, but the far-out giant planet has an eccentric (egg-shaped) orbit.  Planets are thought to form on nearly circular orbits, so the eccentricity of this distant planet’s orbit suggests that it has exchanged energy and angular momentum with another, yet unseen, planet in the past.

More information

The article Mass and Eccentricity Constraints in the WASP-47 Planetary System from a Simultaneous Analysis of Radial Velocities & Transit Timing Variations will be published in The Astronomical Journal. In addition to Lauren Weiss, the team includes Katherine Deck, Evan Sinukoff, Erik A. Petigura, Eric Agol, Eve J. Lee, Juliette C. Becker, Andrew W. Howard, Howard Isaacson, Ian J. M. Crossfield, Benjamin J. Fulton and Lea Hirsch.

The blog post WASP-47: a bizarre planetary system that left clues about how it formed, by Lauren Weiss